Husband: Peter or Isaac Arquette (1)
Wife: Betsey (2)
01 (M): John Arquette (3 4 5 6 7 8 9)
Born: about 1844 in Brasher, St Lawrence, NY (10 11)
Died: after 1920 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Spouses: Hannah Mabel Todhunter; Imogene Judd
  1. John Von Haden, family group sheet received 7 Mar 2010.

    [Certificate of Mariage to Hannah Todhunter gives grooms father's name as Peter,
    Certificate of Mariage to Imogene Judd gives name as Isaac.]

  2. Ibid., Family Group Sheet received 7 Mar 2010.
  3. <>, Arquette and Todhunter (#2) (Email 16 Apr 2003 from Larry Pfaffendorf to Dianne Stevens).
  4. Census, Federal - 1920 - Milwaukee Co., WI, Milwaukee ED # 30, sheet 21, line 62.

    [He is listed as head, single, age 75. He has lodgers.]

  5. Census, Federal - 1880 - Dodge Co, WI, Waupun, Ancestry p. 22, line 47.
  6. Census, Federal - 1870 - Clark Co, WI, town of Loyal, p. 6&7 (Ancestry).
  7. Wisconsin State Prison, Inmate Conduct Records 1854-1946 (microfilm reel 3; AP93-0566; call # Series 1379).

    Record # 471
    John Arquette, #2451, sentenced Dec 11th, '77 for four years, from December 11, 1877 short time expires May 23, 1881, if no black marks reported.

  8. John Von Haden, articles from Port Washington Weekly Star archives.

    John Arquette Stories from Port Washington Weekly Star

    Aug 25, 1883; p. 8, col 3
    Arrested for Bigamy

    John Arket, a character who has been living in this neighborhood for the past few years and who has gained considerable notoriety by his escapades, was arrested last Tuesday by Frank Delles, city marshal, on a charge of bigamy.

    Some two years a go Arket first came into notice on account of a warrant sworn out by a young lady of this city charging him with being the paternal progenitor of an embryo inhabitant, without having first gone through the formality of obtaining a legal pronounciamento declaring them to be man and wife.

    Arket, however, escaped prosecution by marrying the aforesaid miss, whom he almost immediately deserted.

    Reports, is some way, reached the ears of the father-in-law of Arket, that the notorious John had been previously married, and that his wife was still living. Investigation disclosed the fact that the report was apparently true, whereupon City Marshal Delles immediately started for the Oneida reservation some ten Miles west of De Pere, to subpoena the Rev. S. W. Ford, a missionary among the Oneida Indians, who was reported to be the minister who married John to Mrs. Arket No. 1. The marshal accordingly sought out Ford and found him to be a genial and obliging gentleman of about 60 years, from whom he learned that Arket had been married in 1867, in Milwaukee county, and that wife No. 1 was living in Neilsville, at the expense of the town, the considerate John having deserted her.

    The marshal having accomplished his purpose, returned to this city, Mr. Ford promising to come down yesterday afternoon, and appear at the examination, which was set for this morning at 9 o'clock before Court Commissioner Tholen.

    Sep 1, 1883; p. 8, col. 3
    Held for Trial

    John Arket, who was arrested for bigamy last week had his preliminary examination last Saturday before Court Commissioner Tholen.

    The most important witness examined was Rev. S. W. Ford, of the Oneida reservation, who testified as to the fact of Arket's first marriage, which occurred in Milwaukee county in 1867. Ford recognized the prisoner as a person whom he had seen before but could not recollect where or at what place.

    At the conclusion of the examination Arket was held in $1000 bonds, which not being forthcoming, he was remanded to jail, there to await the action of the Circuit Court.

    Sep. 8, 1883; p. 8, col. 3

    John Arquet, who was arrested some time ago for bigamy, had his trial before the Circuit Court this week. Arquet was first married in 1867, to a Miss Todhunter, at Wauwatosa, and afterwards moved to Neilsville, where Mrs. Arquet still lives. Arquet, in 1877, was sentenced to four years in state prison, for horse stealing, in Winnebago county. At the expiration of his term of service, Arquet came to this neighborhood, and worked for several farmers hereabout. Shortly after his arrival here, he married a Miss Judd, to escape a criminal prosecution. In some manner, probably from the indiscreet talk of Arquet himself, the report was started that he had another wife living. The authorities investigating the matter found the report to be true, and caused the man's arrest.

    The case was given to the jury Thursday afternoon, but the evidence was so conclusive that it required but a few minutes to agree on a verdict, which was: guilty.

    Friday, Arquet was brought before Judge Sloan to receive his sentence. The Judge sentenced him to three years in the state prison, and gave him some good advice. Arquet, on receiving his sentence, was moved to tears, and promised to reform when released.

    Sep. 15, 1883; p. 8, col. 3

    John Arquet, who was last week convicted of bigamy by the Circuit Court, and sentenced to three years in state prison, would probably have received a much longer sentence but for several mitigating circumstances. Through the influence of Mr. Tom B. Philpoth, of Loyal, Wis., ex-sheriff of Clark Co., Arquet was prevailed upon to deed his wife, considerable property, which he had acquired during his sojourn in this city, amounting to two or three hundred dollars, and also to transfer what funds he had, some $60, to his wife. These facts were taken into consideration by the judge when sentence was pronounced, and in consequence Arquet escaped with a much lighter sentence than would otherwise have been accorded him. Mr. Philpoth deserves great praise, from the people of Clark County, for having prevailed upon Arquet to relinquish his title to the property, as he, (Philpoth), done a good act for the county and for Mrs. Arquet. Mrs. Arquet is said to be a respectable and hard working woman, who has, with some slight assistance from the town, managed to support herself and five small children. Arquet was conveyed this week to Waupun, by Sheriff Spehn, where he will have an unequaled opportunity for contemplating the folly of disregarding the laws of the great commonwealth of Wisconsin.

  9. Clark Co., WI Internet Library, ALHN & AHGP website (, In the Good Old Days - Clark County News - June 1877.

    The fact was brought to light that the family of John Arquette, deserted by him some time ago, was found to be in a starving condition. Their immediate needs were supplied by contributions solicited by Mrs. James O’Neill, Sr. The town fathers should see that the family is not allowed to starve in the future.

  10. Census, Federal - 1870 - Clark Co, WI, town of Loyal, p. 6 & 7.

    [Per the 1908 newspaper story John was born in 1839]

  11. John Von Haden, copy of Arquuet-Todhunter marriage record from Volume 2, p. 438 at Milwaukee Co. Couthouse.

    [marriage certificate says "Brazier, NY" However, 1850 census shows a Peter and Betsey Arquette family in "Brasher" NY< which I believe is correct spelling.]

Surnames | Index

Revised: February 19, 2018